British Start of International and Relative Law
May be the Doctrine of Ultra Vires Dead? Author(s): R. Baxt Source: The International and Comparative Legislation Quarterly, Volume. 20, Number 2 (Apr., 1971), pp. 301315 Published by: Cambridge University Press on behalf of the British Company of Intercontinental and Relative Law Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/758032. Accessed: 26/04/2013 02: twenty four Your make use of the JSTOR archive implies your approval of the Terms & Circumstances of Use, offered by. http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service in order to scholars, research workers, and college students discover, work with, and build after a wide range of articles in a reliable digital store. We make use of information technology and tools to improve productivity and facilitate fresh forms of grant. For more information regarding JSTOR, make sure you contact [email protected] org.
Cambridge University Press and Uk Institute of International and Comparative Rules are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Foreign and Comparative Law Quarterly.
This content downloaded from 140. 172. 34. 46 on Fri, 26 Interest 2013 02: 48: forty-four AM Almost all use susceptible to JSTOR Conditions
SHORTER ARTICLES, COMMENTS AND NOTES
MAY BE THE DOCTRINE OF ULTRA VIRES DEAD?
MOST traditions expire hard and it seems that, inspite of a long and often
apparently powerful defensive campaign, the followers of the regle of extremely vires could possibly now declare that in the event the doctrine is definitely not lifeless it is only a " walking cadaver. " two In Australia it turned out brought about by two developments, and in the U. K. the first development is predicted shortly being introduced by amendment to the Companies Take action. The first, a lawful development, is viewed in the intro into the Corporations Acts with the various Australian territories and states, of provisions which can be aimed at offering to firms almost unrestricted powers and which are geared towards virtually abolishing the cortege except for limited purposes; several the second is observed in the presentation given to an objects clause in a industry’s memorandum of association which will vests in the directors the strength to carry out no matter what business " they deem will be beneficial to the business. " some In the data given to the Jenkins Panel on Organization Law Change, the supporters and opposing team of the cortege had adequate opportunity to complex their opinions. The former indicated to restored interest in expense. "... we feel that there is a new contest of traders appearing, the tiny man, and think that every thing should be done to ensure that he understands exactly what is happening; if this individual buys shares in a firm he ought to know... the activities of the company... in which he placed his funds. " five The opponent's view is characterised by following affirmation made in the report in the Cohen Panel. 6 "... the cortege of extra vires is an illusory protection to get the investors and may certainly be a pitfall intended for third parties working with the company... the ultra vires doctrine will serve no confident purpose nevertheless is, alternatively, a cause of unnecessary prolixity and mortification. " It is not untrue to suggest that a careful appraisal of the evidence before the Jenkins Committee reveals that the majority of witnesses supported the Generally called ultra vires, although it is definitely occasionally called " extra vires. " This is to become contrasted to illegal actions (see infra) and actions which are beyond the powers of directors. See e. g., Pennington's Organization Law (2nd ed. ) (1967) pp. 144 ou seq. two See Wedderburn " The Death of Ultra Vires" (1966) 30 M. T. R. 673. 3 dure. 19 and 20 of the uniform businesses legislation. This legislation which is uniform people was launched into the numerous states and territories within a short period during and after 61. It is near refer to the various legislation because the uniform Companies Serves. See...